Please welcome author Kristine Cayne back to the Black Velvet Seductions Blog. Kristine has an interesting post on alpha heroes as well as some great questions for our readers. Please join our discussion!
Hi everyone! I’m excited to be visiting the Black Velvet Seductions’ blog again. As some of you may know, I write romantic suspense, which like paranormal romance, is a genre that often has alpha heroes. Today, I’d like to talk about what makes a man an alpha, and why they are sometimes perceived as being asses.
What Makes a Man an Alpha?
There is a tendency for authors to idealize their heroes. This isn’t surprising, of course, since as women we write men the way we think we want them to be. We make them say the things we want to hear. What happens? We write heroes (and sometimes villains) who sound and act like women. We make them ultra PC, with no faults at all. The result is a man whose reactions, thoughts, language, and feelings are toned down. A man who is too perfect to be true.
An alpha is, first and foremost, a leader. He is a person who makes the decisions that no one else will make. He cannot second-guess himself because doing so might mean that someone dies. He makes mistakes, but he is brave enough to own up to them.
The alpha hero must be a match for the villain. His edges might be rough; he might be arrogant; he might be cruel; his thoughts might be extreme or black and white. He might be willing to do things that others find reprehensible in certain situations. He might be a warrior rather than a protector. He might be on the offensive rather than the defensive.
Alphas and Ethics
Particularly in romantic suspense, the hero and heroine (who can also be an alpha) will need to deal with people (villains) who compel them to act in ways they normally wouldn’t. They may need to push the boundaries of what’s ethical to succeed.
Heroes, especially military or law-enforcement type, are often trained killers. Ethics becomes a big issue for them. How far will they go in their quest to succeed in the mission or vanquish the villain? Will they kill? If so, does it have to be justified? They don’t always get to kill in self-defense. They may have to make a choice, a split-second decision. To win, they often need to embrace their darker side, even if they don’t want to.
Alphas and their Mouths
Language and cursing is another tricky issue. Many women don’t like cursing, some even abhor it. As writers, we strive to achieve a balance between being true to the character and not offending (the mostly female) readers. I don’t buy an operative in deep cover with South American drug lords who never swears. I don’t buy a gang leader villain who never swears. That’s not to say all heroes or villains need to swear, but one who doesn’t is a stand-out. Not swearing is a character trait specific to him. Not every hero or villain an author writes can have this same unusual trait.
Alphas and Sex
Just as I don’t buy alphas who never swear, I don’t buy alphas who only ever have ultra-romantic, it’s-all-about-you-baby, missionary sex. Alphas have strong emotions and even stronger desires. Every once in a while, they need to get it their way: hard and fast, up against a wall, in the car, in an alley, in a changing room at the mall. Sometimes your alpha needs it and he needs it right now.
Men, especially alphas, are visual creatures and their vocabulary with regards to sex and sexual body parts is much more graphic than womens’. No alpha will refer to a woman’s pubic area as her mound. He’ll call it a p*ssy, as will most men. I must admit that I’m hesitant to use this word in my writing, because I know many women don’t like it. Still, in my sex scenes from the hero’s point of view, I try to use more direct words and avoid flowery euphemisms.
Alphas and Villains
What then, you might ask, is the difference between an alpha hero and a villain? As I mentioned early, for the suspense part of the story to be believable, the hero and the villain must be evenly matched—they must both be alphas. What sets them apart is that the hero will have his own moral code, a line he will not cross no matter the consequences to himself. An alpha hero may also be willing to make extreme sacrifices for others. No matter how dangerous, or mercenary he is, there is an essential bit of humanity that he never loses. But the villain does.
Reader Expectations
Readers differ in what they want and expect just as much as writers do. I tend to write in deep point of view. I try to get inside the head of my characters and write exactly what they are thinking and feeling. In my new book, Deadly Addiction, when the hero meets the heroine for the first time, he doesn’t realize that she is a police officer. In his mind, he just sees a pretty civilian administrative assistant that he’d like to sleep with. Later, when he learns that he’ll be working with her, he doesn’t understand why she’s been assigned to the task when she looks more like a model than a cop.
I had some comments from early readers that I should tone down his thoughts. That maybe he should think that if got the assignment it was because her superiors thought she was smart and would do a good job. After talking with some of the men in my life, I decided not to tone him down. This is how most men would react. I kept him true to his character, but I did justify his thoughts a little more. And don’t worry, like most men, as he gets to know the heroine, he starts to see beyond her pretty face and comes to admire her intelligence and independence.
Questions for You
As a reader, what are your expectations regarding an alpha hero? Do you like heroes who aren’t very nice? Who aren’t quite tameable? How do you feel about heroes who curse, who have rough sex? Do you like them tough and dangerous, even if you’d never want a man like that in real life?
Or do you like your heroes more sweet, more toned down? More like the men we deal with in our normal lives?
I think your answers might vary depending on the genre of book you prefer, so please include that in your responses.
Synopsis of Deadly Addiction
A proud people. A nation divided.
Rémi Whitedeer, police officer turned substance-abuse counselor, dreams of restoring order to his tribe. Violence and crime are rampant throughout the unpoliced Iroquois reserve, and a civil war is brewing between the Guardians, a militant traditionalist group, and other tribal factions. As the mixed-race cousin of the Guardians’ leader, Rémi is caught in a no-man’s land—several groups lay claim to him, but all want him to deny his white blood.
A maverick cop on an anti-drug crusade.
When she infiltrated the Vipers to take down the leader of the outlaw biker gang responsible for her brother’s death, police sergeant Alyssa Morgan got her man. But her superiors think she went too far. Her disregard for protocol and her ends-justify-the-means ethics have branded her an unreliable maverick. To salvage her career, she accepts an assignment to set up a squad of native provincial officers on a reserve.
A radical sovereigntist bent on freeing a nation.
Decades of government oppression threaten the existence of the Iroquois Nation. But one man, Chaz Whitedeer, is determined to save his people no matter what the price, even if it means delving into the shadowy world of organized crime.
When Rémi and Alyssa uncover the Guardians’ drug-fueled scheme to fund their fight for true autonomy—a scheme involving the Vipers—Rémi must choose between loyalty to family and tribe or his growing love for Alyssa.
Can Rémi and Alyssa leave everything behind—even their very identities—for a future together?
Excerpt from Deadly Addiction
Closing her eyes, Alyssa pressed the glass of water to her neck. “I can do the talking if that makes you feel any better.”
Although Rémi heard the words, it would have taken an act of Parliament to get him to respond.
The heat of her skin caused the condensation on the glass to liquefy. Like a tractor-beam, his gaze followed a drop of water as it slid down the long pale column of her neck, followed the curve of her right breast and slipped under the collar of her blue cotton T-shirt into the V of her cleavage. Oh fuck. He wanted to be that drop of water. He wanted to be snuggled between her warm ripe breasts. His cock swelled and lengthened, letting him know that it wanted to be there too.
He squeezed his lids shut and willed his hard-on away. This wasn’t the time and certainly not the place for Mr. Happy to make an appearance. But the more he tried not to think about where the drop had gone, the more he did. He’d thought he was a leg man, but he knew the truth now. It had slapped him in the face. He was a breast man. An “Alyssa’s breasts” man, and he fucking wanted to see them, to feel them, to taste them. Right now.
About Kristine Cayne
Kristine Cayne is fascinated by the mysteries of human psychology—twisted secrets, deep-seated beliefs, out-of-control desires. Add in high-stakes scenarios and real-world villains, and you have a story worth writing, and reading.
The heroes and heroines of her Deadly Vices series are pitted against each other by their radically opposing life experiences. By overcoming their differences and finding common ground, they triumph over their enemies and find true happiness in each other’s arms.
Today she lives in the Pacific Northwest, thriving on the mix of cultures, languages, religions and ideologies. When she’s not writing, she’s people-watching, imagining entire life stories, and inventing all sorts of danger for the unsuspecting heroes and heroines who cross her path.
Deadly Addiction is available in print and/or e-book format at the following retailers
Amazon ebook: http://amzn.com/B007WNTXR4
Amazon print: http://amzn.com/0984903429
Amazon UK: http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B007WNTXR4
Barnes and Noble: http://bit.ly/JAaX4O
Smashwords: http://www.smashwords.com/books/view/154765
All Romance eBooks: http://www.allromanceebooks.com/product-deadlyaddiction-784712-152.html
Kristine Cayne’s links
New Releases List: (http://site.kristinecayne.com/Newsletter.html) or (https://www.facebook.com/KristineCayneAuthor?sk=app_100265896690345)
Website: (htttp://www.kristinecayne.com)
Blog: (http://kristinecayne.blogspot.com)
Facebook: (http://www.facebook.com/KristineCayneAuthor)
Twitter: (http://twitter.com/KristineCayne)
Goodreads: (http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/5428452.Kristine_Cayne)






















I like to write my one alpha with a bit of a dark side. He take a deeper journey in the novel I’m just finishing. I find the strong silent type intriguing. I love that you are digging deeper into the mind of your hero!
I think they have a strong sex drive and so agree about ‘vanilla’ sex.
I had fun in one of my novels by putting two alpha males together. They were both competing and working together to save the heroine. It was fun to write.
I want reality, flaws and all.
Great post.
Hi Jodi! Reality – flaws and all. Yes! That’s what I want too. I don’t want sugar-coated guys (good or bad). Just as I don’t want all my male characters to be alphas, but the heroes? For sure
Thank you for stopping by and commenting.
Good blog, Kristine! Who doesn’t love an alpha male? And yet, those quiet beta males can seem pretty intriguing. You’ve inspired me. I’d love to have a beta male as a hero in one of my stories.
I appreciate what you said about the balance act of writing an agressive male model and pleasing your female readers at the same time. It’s easy (and okay, fun!) to write over the top sometimes.
It is so easy and fun to write over-the-top alphas. But I do like mine to be a combination of alpha and beta, I guess you could say. At some point in the story, they need to show their vulnerability. If they are he-men all the time, I get bored
Thanks for your comment, Kate!
Hi Kristine! I love heroes with rough edges, so I’m glad you didn’t sanitize yours. I like my men to be men, not women in men’s bodies. However, I don’t want them to be horrible jerks either, especially to the women in their lives. I quit reading romance in the 80′s because too many of the heroes were asses. There’s a happy medium, and I think you’ve hit it with your books. I love the parts in your books where the guys are giving each other crap and calling each other names because that’s real–your guys sound like guys!
Dana – thank you so much. It really was tempting to tone-down my guys but then if I had, they wouldn’t be my guys! I do make a point of showing them in different lights so the readers learn different aspects of their personalities. Their tough when they need to be, and oh-so-gentle when they need to be
I read a lot of paranormal and erotic romance so I see my share and more of alpha males. I like an alpha that has some faults but is a good man and loves with all his heart. I quickly get bored with sappy men and ones who let the woman walk all over them. I also think that a beta man can be just as sexy as the main alpha.
Gabrielle, you make a great point about the beta. I think we tend to view the beta as weak, rather than as the second in command. I too like the idea of an “ordinary” man called upon to be extraordinary. I think what it all comes down to is that we like a man to be a man (and not a wuss)
Thank you for stopping by and commenting!
I definitely like the idea of the ordinary man called upon to be extraordinary. In some ways that is more exciting than the exceptional man doing what comes naturally…or what seems natural.
I’m reading a book now by Nora Roberts…THE SEARCH…in which the hero is a furniture maker…just a normal man…who meets the heroine because he has an obnoxious dog and she is an exceptional dog trainer. The heroine has a backstory of having escaped a serial killer…and being the target of his apprentice in this story. It strikes me that the hero in this book is just a very ordinary guy…not very socially adept…not a cop or an ex warrior…just a normal, very ordinary guy…who I expect will be called upon to be extraordinary during the course of the story.
I’m liking this ordinary hero. He’s strong. He’s successful in his chosen career. But he isn’t a leader…he’s barely social.
I wouldn’t call him alpha…or beta. He’s more ordinary, normal guy who I expect will be called to go to extraordinary means for his heroine.
He’s certainly not a wuss…but he’s definitely not an alpha either.
I’m finding him interesting…partly because he IS different from the norm.
Alpha either you love them or leave. Or fight them. I love the tense and power of attactions they can create with the heroine. Great blog. Thanks
I agree with you Mary. I like the power of alphas. Since they are usually less flexible than betas I tend to like the tension that stems from a heroine who doesn’t want to bend and a hero who won’t…or who thinks he won’t.
Exactly – who thinks he won’t. But match him up with the right woman and he’s like a flexi-straw. LOL
Indeed…and don’t we love to see the tough guy bend for the right woman?
One of the things I like most about alphas (at least how I portray them) is that when they fall for a woman, they fall hard. They fall completely. Their passion is exciting! Thank you for the comment, Mary!
It all depends on the type of story. Some curse words and/or sex scenes are necessary in certain types of books.
Wilma – so true! Cursing and sex scenes need to be used when they make sense in the story. It’s painfully obvious when such things are added or, conversely, omitted in such a way that does not suit the story or the characters. Great comment. Thank you!
I love this post Kristine! I love that you didn’t feel the need to change the male’s thoughts because some people thought it needed toned down. I love it when authors can get inside their character’s minds and write realistically.
My preferred genre is PNR/suspense, and I LOVE an alpha male…at least in my books! I go for the tough bad boy type, but he still has to know how to treat a lady right.
Thank you so much, Sheri. I really do try to write my male characters’ thoughts as close as I can to how men really think, not how I’d like them to think. The two rarely match
WOW, you really bring up a great point, the way the heroes and villans talk and act in books. As has been mentioned, in historical romance novels gentlemen and ladies of the period would (mostly) act and talk in a gentile manner (but certainly not pirates, thugs and evil people). However, in contemporary, paranormal, sci-fi, etc. actions and language should fit the time/place/and cercumstances. An LA gang “shot-caller” isn’t going to sound like an English Professor nor act like a Catholic Priest. Language and actions, if inappropriate on the part of an alpha could spell his or her death as they might well be seen as an undercover cop or weak. In my opinion, it must be up to the author to use his or her feelings for the male and female characters in their story. My “Immortal Relations” (paranormal romance), has a warning, “THIS IS AN ADULT STORY AND IS DEFINITELY NOT FOR CHILDREN!” I’d thought about adding a comma with “OR THE PRUDISH” but, I thought the prudish will realize the book will have things they wouldn’t like to hear.
I’d expect the prudish would recognize that a story for adults and not for children might wonder if they would like the content. Seems like fair warning to me.
Now you’ve made me want to check out your book, G.! There’s nothing I find more disconcerting than a supposed tough-guy who talks like he’s at Sunday school, unless that’s how the character is supposed to be. And your right, if your character is a an undercover cop, he can’t sound like one. He has to sound as bad and mean as the people he’s infiltrated. Thank you for your comment!
I like my heros to be heroic but that doesn’t mean they can’t cuss and act like men. I don’t know any men who don’t swear at sometime or other. I want my Alpha’s to be that Alpha’s. They need to be strong and fierce, but they also need to have that gentle side that they occasionally show the heroine.
I think your book sounds really interesting. Loved the excerpt. Definitely going on my TBR pile.
Thank you so much, Cynthia! I can’t wait to hear how you like it. I’m like you, my alphas need to be tough, even badass, when it’s called for, but sensitive, even vulnerable with the heroine. After all, isn’t letting yourself be vulnerable to the one you love a sign of true courage? Glad you could stop by!
My preferred genre is Historical Romance, so as you may expect I like my heroes to be Gentlemen. Even the Rakes know the rules.
You bring up a great point Mary. There are a lot of alphas in historical romance…but I think that, particularly some historical time periods, have alphas who’ve had more of their rough edges sanded off.
Regency romance for example have pretty tame heroes. Even the rakes are mild compared to some of the modern day alphas.
But I think too that alpha heroes are the norm rather than the exception in romance in general. Heroes who do not lead, who cannot make a decision to save their soul, who are not strong and powerful in their own right (whether they throw their weight around or not) would likely not be well received.
Even the less alphas of the heroes have certain alpha qualities. The ability to lead if called upon, for example.
So…what of alphas in historical romance? Are the heroes in historical romance less alpha or do they just express it differently than the heroes in romantic suspense, paranormal, and erotic romance do?
What are the rules for alphas in historicals?
Laurie – I agree. In most historicals that I read, the heroes had alpha qualities. They were able to protect and defend their chosen lady either with their brawn or their brains.
I think some alphas in historical romance are just as alpha as those in modern romances (think about all the dark dukes with the mysterious even deadly pasts). But in all genres, there is a range of alpha types (i.e. think geek turned alpha, intellectual earl forced to fight for his woman, etc.)
Fascinating subject
I agree. Heroes are always a good topic.
I agree that heroes in historicals have alpha qualities. Sometimes however it is a bit hidden by a veneer of what is appropriate for the time period.
Most romances have heroes who have some alpha traits. The traits may be hidden a bit…or may need to be coaxed out by events or situations…but heroes do rise to the occasion…often in alpha or alpha tinged ways. It’s what they do. It’s what makes them heroes.
That’s not at all to say that a beta geek can’t be sexy…but I think we tend to like heroes that take charge, make decisions when they are called upon to do so. It goes back to what you said about them not being wusses.
I believe the heroes in Historical Romance often don’t feel the need to flex their muscles as much. I’m not talking Vikings or Highlanders here, because their appeal is often their physical attributes.
Hi Mary, I used to read a lot of Historical Romance, and still do but to a lesser extent. The rakes knew the rules, or at least they did by the end of the story.
Thank you so much for your comment.
Though I guess it could be pointed out that one thing that makes a rake a rake is his willingness to break the rules.
Good point, Laurie! I’ll amend that to they knew how to break the rules and not get caught
Till the one time they DID get caught…which sometimes in historical romances with rakes is how the book gets started.
I think perhaps it’s the getting caught that causes them to be labeled a rake.
Yes! And the more compromising the situation, the more fun it is to see them “reform” through the book. Thanks, Mary!